The North Carolina General Assembly meets in the State Legislative Building in Raleigh, seen here in Feb. 2018. This is part 2 of the four-part investigative series Patchwork Protection produced by Kate Martinfor the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalisms 2020 Data Fellowship. Many of the counties with very high removal rates have elevated poverty rates, but no direct correlation exists between poverty levels and child removal rates. The sad part is Jane Shooter, Pam Bright Prichard, Karen Ellis Prichard and others should have been fired 25 years ago. We have a broken child welfare system that we refuse to invest in, Blevins said. Because of that, we placed one of our staff at the hospital. Buncombe County has an average of 1,600 employees who serve as sheriff deputies, nurses, social workers, librarians, emergency medical workers, park rangers, environmental health specialists, planners, tax assessors, administrators and more - all working to serve the residents of Buncombe County. Please contact the developer of this form processor to improve this message. A good many are probably false or contain half-truths. Zahra Baker was a native of Australia who lived in Catawba County with her father and stepmother. However, even with the subpoena, a county spokeswoman said Blevins would be limited in what he could reveal about the specific incident. . Phone: 828-250-5500 Legislators in the Joint Legislative Oversight Committee on Health and Human Services voted 15-8 along party lines Tuesday in favor of subpoenaing Buncombe Health and Human Services Director Stoney Blevins, with Republicans in favor and Democrats against. A state legislative committee has voted to subpoena Buncombe County's Health and Human Services director to get answers as to why a social worker thought it was appropriate to leave a 9-year-old . Although Noyes had previously assisted in caring for her daughters children and remained willing to do so, DSS ultimately removed them instead and persuaded the court to place the children with their father. Carolina Public Press provides in-depth, investigative reporting on issues affecting Western North Carolina in a nonprofit, nonpartisan setting. Kate Martin is lead investigative reporter for Carolina Public Press. One relative was convicted last year and is serving a 12-year prison sentence, another is serving a suspended sentence of five years, and a third is serving a two-year prison sentence. New Jersey officials ruled the case a suicide, but a Carolina Public Press investigation identified problems with this explanation that have never been resolved. Noyes said she continues to work with her daughter to regain custody of the children but has become disappointed by the process. She was concerned the children could be injured if he attacked her. The parents used intravenous drugs in the presence of their children and failed to provide adequate nutrition and hygiene, the indictments said. Click a goal. This statute was initiated to protect the increasing number of disabled adults in North Carolina who are being abused, neglected or exploited. Once a referral is taken for Protective Services, a Social Worker will be assigned the case. In a case of suspected abuse in a foster care setting, DSS is obligated to notify law enforcement. The law gave DHHS authority to enforce performance standards at each county, and for DHHS to take over DSS offices that chronically underperform an authority DHHS used a few months later when it took over Cherokee Countys child welfare division. Kate Martin is lead investigative reporter for Carolina Public Press. But sometimes social workers fudge. She told the police she wanted to go home. I ended the phone call.. We would never support leaving a child in a hotel room with a stranger and 300 used needles, as a blanket statement, Blevins said last year. Lets start meeting and talking and get ready to kick these rats out. Such records are typically open to prosecutors, according toPeg Dorer, with the N.C. Conference of District Attorneys. Carolina Public Press is an independent nonprofit news organization dedicated to nonpartisan, in-depth and investigative news built upon the facts and context North Carolinians need to know. 2001 Mail Service Center There appeared to be no attempt by the police or DSS to follow up with the Sheriffs Office. A simple takeaway from the map is that the state has many counties at either end of the spectrum, far removed from the statewide average. The General Assembly called Buncombe County Health and Human Services DirectorStoney Blevinsto testify about the incident. State Sen. Chuck Edwards said during the hearing that police officers were told by a social worker to leave the girl in a hotel room with a man she didnt know. #828-479-7911 Fax #828-479-7928 Courier Number: 08-40-02. Box 7408 State Courier #: 12-50-02 Phone: 828-250-5500 Fax Number: 828-250-6235 Emergency Phone: 828-250-5500 Website Key Staff Director: Stoney Blevins Administrative Assistant: Christa Lance , 828-250-5587 The programs are housed in three separate locations. Tracy Jones, who was DSS director in Transylvania County in 2016 but not during the time of the foster care abuse allegation, told CPP that the agencys procedure during an adoption is always to notify the next of kin first. This is your chance to support credible, community-based, public-service journalism. Agency Name. Are new people living there? Food Network's 'Spring Baking Championship' to feature WNC pastry chef, After first clean audit in 4 years, Buncombe County again has 'significant deficiency', Buncombe County Commissioners discuss affordable housing, cryptocurrency, finances, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. If you would like to obtain posters or rack cards, please email hhscommunications@buncombecounty.org, Social Work Services If you like what you are reading and believe in independent, nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism like oursjournalism the way it should beplease contributeto keep us going. The largest concentration of counties that are removing children at high or very high rates are in the western mountain counties, though a smaller cluster also exists in the southeastern counties, and a few other exceptions are scattered across the map. Addison was placed in foster care in Transylvania County. Buncombe County DSS Mr. Stoney Blevins, Director 828-250-5588. Im so disgusted with the system. Categories. People who lose their children or are unsuccessful in having children removed from the home of a troubled family member are not happy about these outcomes. Reeves family said she had lived in fear for her life because of attacks from her ex-husband Titus Boley, who had served a prison sentence for assaulting her. This report has not been officially confirmed, but my sources are reliable. If you like what you are reading and believe in independent, nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism like oursjournalism the way it should beplease contributeto keep us going. The case made international headlines over the following months, focusing a world spotlight on the total failure of the child protection system in her case. In 2016, Rylan Ott, nearly 2 years old, wandered from his Carthage home and drowned in a pond. Buncombe County Health & Human Services Address: 40 Coxe Ave., Asheville, NC 28801 P.O. Report and copy of Lawsuit provided by Robert A. Williams, Cleveland County Republicans in Civil War!! {{#message}}{{{message}}}{{/message}}{{^message}}Your submission failed. Child welfare officials rank reported cases of abuse and respond either immediately, within 24 hours or within 72 hours depending on the severity of the allegation. Fax Number: 828-250-6341 Family members had warned social workers multiple times she was in danger and had received no response from DSS, according to the Smoky Mountain News. Men Against the Women!! As a result, the family said, the statute of limitations had expired, and no one could be charged two years later. He is earning a salary of $102,755.32, according to a public records request. An Associated Press investigation into Littlejohns death found social workers forged documents to cover their tracks after the girl died to show the visits had occurred when they in fact had not. I ended the phone call.. "I'm still kind of young in my career. Please help support this type of journalism with asubscriptionto the Citizen Times. Social Worker Investigative/Assessment and Treatment. The Social Services Director will be responsible for setting strategy and direction for all Department of Social Service programs, being a change agent for the organization, and building a cohesive DSS team. Not long afterward, he died of an overdose. A parents attorney could get a hold of these records and make an argument to have the kids returned home.. Must be able to type a minimum of 40 words per minute. Blevins pointed out that the police report says the officer hung up on the DSS worker who was trying to take the report. Although she filed a complaint, she said it was not taken seriously. CPP is not naming the adults because naming them could identify the young children. They may think the system has wronged their families. Jim Perry is so clueless: the purpose of an oversight committee is to provide oversight and rude. She died in 2010, and her stepmother was eventually charged in her murder. They described social workers ignoring judges instructions on keeping families together, social workers who acted on personal dislike of their families and irreversible adoptions that did not follow policy or the law and inappropriately kept family members in the dark about what was happening. A social worker ordered a family to banish the family dog, who had bitten no one. Records from Reeves communications during the final weeks of her life show that she was repeatedly at odds with DSS agents over her son, though what she knew about his location was not clear. The legal and bureaucratic system surrounding child removals can be difficult to navigate, so that even social workers from one county may find aspects of how things are done in another county quite alien, and the average person is unable to make sense of whats happening. A parents attorney could get a hold of these records and make an argument to have the kids returned home.. Carolina Public Press is an independent nonprofit news organization dedicated to nonpartisan, in-depth and investigative news built upon the facts and context North Carolinians need to know. But the map also shows that the high and very high counties mostly cluster geographically, as do the low and very low counties. A social worker ordered a family to banish the family dog, who had bitten no one. Reliable sources also report that CCDSS Interim Director Jane Shooter is mad as a hornet that she was NOT promoted to the CCDSS Director position. In some cases, people may have kept enough records and can present a credible account shored up by documentation. Officers discovered hundreds of used needles along with drugs in the room. The purpose of intake questions is to determine how urgently a case needs the governments attention. Key Staff Polk County Health and Human Services Director: Joshua Kennedy. Their stories were often shocking and always emotional. Response times to child welfare reports vary depending on how much risk the child is in. Her school reported abuse, and multiple social workers visited the family. He told officers that he had met the girl for the first time that day and volunteered to watch her. Frank Taylor is the managing editor of Carolina Public Press. A horrific child sex abuse case in Cherokee County two years ago included apuzzling delayby DSS officials in cooperating with prosecutors. Box 7408 The Director serves as the executive officer of the county board of social services executing the authority of the board as defined in GS 108A14. Select a county on the map to view phone numbers, websites, physical addresses and mailing addresses. Address: 231 Wolverine Trail, Mill Spring, NC 28756 State Courier #: 06-74-02 Phone: 828-894-2100 Fax Number: 828-894-6326 Emergency Phone: 828-894-0187 Website. At one point, the report says, she advised officers to leave the girl in the custody of Stanley.. Some families accused DSS staff of generally playing God with peoples lives and acting in a conspiratorial manner. But the map also shows that the high and very high counties mostly cluster geographically, as do the low and very low counties. Emergency Phone: 828-250-5500Website, Administrative Assistant: Christa Lance,828-250-5587, Business Officer/ Fiscal/Performance Manager: Lisa White,828-250-5802, Operation Manager: Leigh Anderson,828-250-5575, Economic Services Division Director: Phillip Hardin,828-250-5592, Social Work Services Division Director/Foster Care & Adoptions Program Administrator: Rebecca Smith,828-250-5764, Permanency Planning: Amber Cook, 828-250-5824, CPS Intake/Investigations: Sherrie Thomas, 828-250-5843 ; Trina Hill, 828-250-5249, Licensing & Adoptions: Lizzi Shimer, 828-250-5277, Adult Services: Jennifer Teague, 828-250-5198, Quality Assurance, Program Administrator: Kelli Buckner,828-250-5987, Quality Assurance, Social Work Performance Standards: Alison Mann,828-250-5788, Family & Adult Medicaid Program Administrator: Ian Allen,828-250-5628, FNS/Program Integrity/Community Resources: Patricia Wallin,828-250-5689, FNS/Technical Support/Training: Denise Lancaster,828-250-5639, Child Support Enforcement: Our award-winning, breakthrough journalism dismantles barriers and shines a light on the critical overlooked and under-reported issues facing our states 10.2 million residents. Officers located needles on the beds, the nightstands, TV stand and the bathroom. Reporting like this isnt free to produce and we cannot do this alone. Social workers removed him from the foster care setting, but the family remained unclear about what happened to him next, they told CPP. Scott has a bachelor's degree in German from Wake Forest University and a masters degree in project management from Western Carolina University, according to the county's news release. Upcoming articles in this series will examine the systemic problems that create challenges for child protective services in North Carolina and potential solutions. In the upcoming election we can kick out this majority fool board. Inside were three adults and a 9-year-old girl, the police report of the traffic stop says. ASHEVILLE - Buncombe County's Public Health. But when public officials do not abide by the laws, they take an oath to, to stand for, then our system is in trouble. This interpretation of the rules can make it difficult for other branches of state government to hold DSS agencies accountable for possible mistakes, much less the news media, which has no access to subpoena powers. But even in some of these cases, legal counsel may ultimately advise them not to discuss the situation further. Don Warn, 53, who was the Buncombe County finance director since November 2018, recently left Buncombe County to go to Guilford County, where he started on Feb. 13, according to a Guilford County news release. They have anywhere from immediately to 72 hours to respond to the case, depending on the seriousness of the situation. A later independent investigation into Moore Countys Department of Social Services revealed that overworked caseworkers did not visit the mother as they were supposed to, and the department did not properly supervise its caseworkers to ensure they followed state law and policy, according to the Fayetteville Observer. I truly hope in this process that this confidentiality requirement isnt being used to hide the mistakes, Hise said. Katie Swanson was hired by the county at the end of May to take over from Karen Pritchard, who retired as DSS director at the end of 2018. He was appointed by the Buncombe County Board of Commissioners to take over the role that has oversight over all county spending, after working for Buncombe County for 11 years across many different departments. Colby Rabon / Carolina Public Press Their stories were often shocking and always emotional. Related:After first clean audit in 4 years, Buncombe County again has 'significant deficiency', County Government:Buncombe County Commissioners discuss affordable housing, cryptocurrency, finances, "We can never really know what a particular environment will look like in any given year, but I lean to those relationships, so maintaining trust and communication both within and outside the organization," he said. But Reeves death was only part of the case. The police reported that an officer called Buncombe County DSS but then hung up on the social worker. If county officials decide to go beyond the scope of state guidelines, or in some cases beyond what state and federal laws allow, those choices are being made by individuals, some of whom already face criminal prosecution. One was located in a glove inside a door pocket, a police report says. Bakers stepmother was already the subject of previous abuse findings. Officers told her they might take him to jail and sarcastically asked if he should leave the girl alone in the hotel room. This will reduce capacity to one active hopper and operational delays should be expected. The report says a social worker told police that DSS did not respond to these situations., Officers explained that the parent wanted to leave the girl with Stanley. The report says the DSS worker demanded multiple times to take a report over the phone. The officer wrote in his report, I told her I did not have time to do that, I had to find a safe place for the child. I thought we were waiting for them to copy the records.. An official website of the State of North Carolina, Mental Health, Developmental Disabilities, and Substance Abuse, Office Of Minority Health And Health Disparities, Services for the Deaf and the Hard of Hearing. To be perfectly honest, I just think we need to take action.. Forging contact records is not trivial. So, we fund a position to work at the hospital so that we can respond to these situations as soon as that baby is delivered.