Looks like youve been wearing it in the wrong position for 4 years , Thanks for the in depth Whoop review. In my opinion, each one fulfills a purpose by bridging the other devices gaps although there are a few areas in which their features overlap. Instead, you can sign up for a WHOOP membership in the form of a monthly subscription for as little as $18 per month. The WHOOP Strap uses that sensor to detect if the unit has good contact with the skin. I hate having to wear multiple devices and dont think the Whoop is for long.. the Apple Watch isnt a good sleep tracker for numerous reasons. For example, if your current strain score is 5.0 and then you go for a run that clocks in at 10.0, your total strain score is likely lower than the sum of both (15.0). I have used Whoop for a couple of years and have benchmarked it with chest straps and/or Apple Watch for Crossfit, running, and cycling and the Polar OH1 HRM against the temple and on the goggle strap for swimming. In theory, WHOOP 4.0 should be more accurate than WHOOP 3.0 because of the additional LEDs and photodiodes. The most commonly used heart-rate-based formula for estimating caloric consumption during activity, or so called active calories, was developed in South Africa in 2005. So Im curious if WHOOP has any plans to add stress and seizure monitoring to its platform in the future. Weight: 150 lbs. Since the WHOOP Strap doesnt have any buttons or a display, you cant tell the device to start tracking a workout routine. If you are, youre either overtraining or something else is going on that requires your attention. If you feel curious and want a deeper look into this whole issue, I highly recommend the book Going Somewhere by Andrew Marino, a PhD biophysicist and JD whos been involved in successful legal action against power companies and wireless companies. Therefore, youll wake up with a relatively low strain, since your body is still using energy and burning calories while youre asleep. Thanks! Note: If your WHOOP 4.0 battery drains quickly (i.e., in less than two days), try restarting it via the mobile app (Device Settings > Advanced > Reboot Device). @gavinkerr95. Thanks you for your post if was very informative. (Thats likely because of the factors Ive mentioned several times throughout the article.). Once youve signed up for WHOOP and notice issues, reach out to membership services immediately to get on the new algorithm. Given that, the Whoop strain is off and can give inaccurate advice. The report visualizes your current training state based on your daily strain, your rate of recovery, and your sleep performance. I did the tap test in my office while wearing WHOOP and a Polar chest strap. And again, credible perspectives (such as a Lancet paper youll find below) suggest the answer is yes (again, for AC electricity in the Hz range, Khz, and Mhz/Ghz radiofrequency radiation). Also in your experience, have you noticed better performance with crossfit workouts on the days Whoop scores your recovery as high and conversely poor performance on low recovery score days? For example, by answering a few simple questions every day, WHOOP can tell you how alcohol use impacts your sleep performance and/or resting heart rate. WHOOP is a fitness tracking wrist strap that works with a companion mobile app to provide unique health insights. The problem is that certain movements cause WHOOP (and other wrist-worn devices that use optical heart rate sensors) to incorrectly report a higher heart rate than you actually have. Seems legit to me. I would agree with your conclusions, except that integrations are crucial and will kill Whoop unless they grow and mature the offer. Great review. WHOOP released an algorithm update that impacts user calorie burn estimation. The table below gives you an overview of how the WHOOP Strap compares to the Apple Watch, Biostrap, Fitbit Sense and Oura Ring. I dont use WHOOP teams a lot but Im a member of several teams and enjoy sharing my WHOOP data with family members and close friends from my CrossFit box. Strain Coach is personalized to your baseline, and constantly adjusts to your daily output. WHOOP can monitor and correlate data from its various sensors to understand when and why your skin temperature deviates from your baseline, which is helpful for predicting the onset of a fever or a menstrual cycle. From missing nights data to not recognizing activities, and an inability to correctly record sleep (even after manually updating it to correlate to my other devices). I have been debating between products such as Whoop, Fitbit, and the Apple watch. Thanks Jeff and good question! Its really not up for debate. Wearables quantify, but they don't describe. Ive now been wearing WHOOP since January 2019, and the data it has provided has been incredibly insightful. You can learn more about how I make money here. Emily Capodilupo is VP of Data Science and Research at WHOOP. Here are some more thoughts, since you also seem to enjoy nerding out. Discussion of all things related to the Whoop Strap Fitness Tracker, and the training, recovery, and cardiovascular load analysis it performs. Thanks for the link to your comprehensive evaluation. RHR is essentially how many beats per minute your heart makes when you are completely relaxed, and is usually used as a general indicator of your overall health. Wow, my body doesnt recover well at all. Whoops lack of adequate integration is, therefore, I conclude, its ultimate failure. On the ingestion side, it is important to understand all the limitations on accurate calorie counting, even with the most diligent and intentional tracking practices: A more exhaustive review of all challenges with accurately counting calories can be found in a 2013 issue of Scientific American. Related: How Apollo Neuroscience has helped me improve my HRV, sleep and my recovery time. I do see some minor discrepancies between my Apple Watch, WHOOP and the chest strap but Im not sure which device is most accurate. While I dont care about that (I just rinse my bands whenever I take a shower), it could be an issue for those who work in the medical field, where contamination with germs can be a problem. Late meals decrease the quality of my sleep (they result in less slow-wave and REM sleep). While Ive never seen WHOOP overestimate my sleep need, my wifes WHOOP Strap 3.0 keeps telling her that she sleeps too much. The application menu is the fifth and last icon in the menu bar and it enables you to make changes to your WHOOP account, change activity detection settings, explore app integrations with Strava or TrainingPeaks, update the Straps firmware and more. 720 vs. 1900 calories. Much like EDA, your skin temperature changes in certain conditions, such as during strenuous exercise, when you have a fever, or during certain parts of the menstrual cycle. If your strap is bad, youll get it replaced. As a result, I build very little cardiovascular strain. Do you worry about EMFs with wearing a smart watch? The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requires that food labels are accurate within 20%, but studies have shown that food labels are more likely to underestimate caloric content than they are to overestimate it. Yesterday the Whoop had me at 1,572, which is a huge difference. It turns out there is no such thing as a free lunch. Are people really that unaware and so determined to believe what a device is telling them? She has been a long-time contributor to The Locker and enjoys bringing the athletes human side of the story to life. From a pure fitness tracking perspective, Fitbit is like my Apple Watch: both provide some value, but if it wasnt for things like notifications, timekeeping and Apple Pay, I wouldnt be wearing it. Whats crucial is that WHOOP uses the collected data to calculate your daily strain. Oura is always wildly off and Im not entirely sure why that is. These calories are the ones you have the most control over and the primary reason why our caloric needs can vary so much from day to day. The Watch tells me Im burning a total of about 3,200 cals per day (same as my old Fitbit); Whoop has me at around 2,100 cals on the same day. Ill make sure to update this review and my how accurate is WHOOP article. 2 questions: The community icon allows you to create or join teams of fellow WHOOP owners and to share strain, recovery and sleep metrics with them. Regardless of the feature set in the software or data, if the thing is not reliable, it is worthless. (losing weight vs gaining strength, etc.) I must say you hit some decent wattage numbers on the Carol bike 20 sec sprint. Also, you might find this article interesting for your journey towards a healthier life: https://michaelkummer.com/health/healthy-lifestyle-guide/. Michael, danke fuer dieser Artikel es is sehr hilflich! The goal with WHOOP strain is to balance it with your recovery days, so you know when to rest and when to push. WHOOP normally recognizes when you remove the strap from your wrist. That enables you to improve your sleep and performance by making adjustments to those lifestyle factors. EEG + ACC + SC + ST boosted the accuracy to 96%. Below is an example of Recovery recorded over a 6-month period. Im incredibly competitive (primarily with myself), and Im in a constant battle with my mind during workouts. Your sleep doctor reminds me of my primary care physician, who still thinks saturated fat intake increases my risk of developing coronary heart disease despite meta analysis of numerous clinical trials stating the opposite. Press J to jump to the feed. You can learn more about HRV and how to improve it in this blog post and YouTube video. Lifetime membership: $399 one-time payment (only available to founding members). Have you tried the Biostrap? Really great article, thank you for posting. Once reconnected, the app will fetch the missing data from the strap and sync it to the cloud. Considering what I wrote above about the limitations of tracking cardiovascular strain, I use WHOOPs recovery percentage as a general guideline for my training load and how much stress I should expose my body to. When you receive the email with the log data, extract the zip file and open the log. Because we're desk-bound, lazy, half-slept or distracted, this turns out to . Im inclined to think that Apple might have to increase the battery life of its watch before it can continuously track your HR and HRV, like Whoop does. For example, endurance training such as running, biking or swimming often causes your heart rate to stay elevated for extended periods. This means that a workout estimated to consume 1000 calories could have easily burnt 734 to 1266 calories a massive difference if you are trying to use this information to modify your body composition. 1) Im not aware that you could use WHOOP to capture SpO2 data during the day. In order to access your WPA, you need at least 14 Recoveries since you started. Just received my WHOOP 3.0 and have not found in any literature what is the preferred hand to wear the device. Two other huge issues, which ultimately would be the reason for purchasing: 1) on days where I literally do nothing it has me showing as having a strain level higher than 91% of users, and days where I run 21 miles it barely notices a difference. If you dont have time to read the full comparison article, below is an overview of the major differences: Overall, I can say that Biostrap has a couple of interesting features, such as blood oxygen monitoring and support for chest straps. Thus going gym without Oura is not a problem for me as none of these wearables are something that gives me useful data and during the sports I always wear a HR real strap. I have been using it for a few weeks and like the data. The biggest selling point for me is the sleep tracker and sleep coach Whoop has to offer. Thats because the WHOOP app supports various input options, including taping and swiping to reveal different information. I do BodyPump one day a week but then do a 3 mile morning walk 5 times a week. Sometimes people living in cities even get really lucky and their sleeping quarters are acceptably low EMF, at least when they do the basic work to not contribute EMFs at home. However, I consider myself relatively in-tune with my body and I continue wearing WHOOP because I keep learning as the platform evolves. Some WHOOP users damaged their battery pack when they forgot to remove it before jumping into the shower. But she feels better and more rested by sleeping longer than what WHOOP recommends. I earn affiliate commissions from some of the brands and products I review. I know several women wearing Whoop, some even with the fancy-looking gold strap. If youre still using WHOOP 3.0 and are wondering whether you should get the latest release, I provide a side-by-side comparison down below, along with my recommendation. I am not an athlete, I am in my early 60s, out of shape, work too many hours sitting on my tail and have terrible sleep habits. During some nights, I noticed a difference in HRV of 1 ms, but that was likely due to differences in capturing time. I think thats a terrible business practice: refuse to provide the service already paid for. But in a nutshell, yes, I believe that WHOOP will provide you with better and more reliable data than the Apple Watch + any app. The way we prepare food can alter its caloric density. Thats the only official, regulatory standard for harm. Considering that Im a die-hard Apple fan and love my Apple Watch, I wasnt sure if I would continue wearing the WHOOP Strap after I was done testing it for this review. If you experience this issue, just reach out to WHOOP membership services via the mobile app and theyll send you a new sensor. The comparison table above shows an example of WHOOP 3.0s potential over-reporting. While small changes to these formulas have been made in the century since, they still largely remain intact. For example, after having consumed two glasses of red wine relatively close to my bedtime, my resting heart rate increased to 60 beats per minutes (which is relatively high for me). Thanks for publishing the comment and your thoughtful reply. I have woken up several times with a high recovery score while feeling sore or even completely unmotivated to work out.The interesting thing is that how we feel doesnt always reflect how our body is doing. Your WHOOP cycle begins when you fall asleep, then resets the next time you fall asleep (some other wearables operate on a fixed 24 hour cycle, which isnt an accurate portrayal of your bodys routine). Accuracy/Precision follow fast but being accurate but unreliable is a deal breaker. The biggest difference between my lowest WHOOP recovery and my highest? The Whoop 4.0 can also track skin temperature and blood oxygen levels, two . Last Updated: Jan 11, 2023. Ive had the whoop for about a week now and Im getting ridiculously low total calories burned. (Ill explain what a strain score is in a bit, so hang tight! If youre having issues with your strap especially if you were an early adopter of WHOOP 3.0 you might have a defective unit. I have worn it during those and do okay, but would prefer to be safe and protect it. I dont rely on it to know my caloric output at all. They have done that with other members as well. The gyroscope detects any changes in WHOOPs orientation triggered by wrist movement. Workouts that are written to Apple Health (or Google Fit) are automatically imported, but more as a journalling feature: the ring makes its prognosis primarily based on data it captures while sleeping, or being still (itll automatically detect a nap, and show change in HRV if one medidates. With the release of iOS 13 and the launch of the iPhone 11 and iPhone 11 Pro, Apple doubled down on extending the battery life of its devices. That depends a little bit on your definition of good. What I can tell you is that WHOOP is incredibly reliable and accurate see above. But based on everything I know about how WHOOP calculates your sleep need (and based on my personal experience), I think you should follow WHOOPs recommendations. In other words, the device can tell you how hard your cardiovascular system worked on a given day. A loose-fitting strap that prevents the sensor from maintaining good contact with the skin. So yeah, I think the biceps band would be an excellent choice for your needs. you dont have to be a gym rat for Whoop to make sense in particular the sleep and strain tracking and analysis. @brobal. It is impossible to gain a truly accurate picture of total health and wellbeing without blood sugar, hydration, weight, muscle mass, body fat, basal metabolism and many other factors which need to be measured and analysed constantly as part of the holistic health equation. Outside of the lab studies WHOOP has performed, they also published a real-life study with college athletes you can check it out here: https://www.whoop.com/the-locker/study-rhr-hrv-sleep-collegiate-athletes/. 5) Light Exercise. No big deal. If you cancel, the strap becomes a paperweight :). The only limitation I see is around automatic workout detection. Sleep Efficiency is therefore a measure of sleep quality, and when considered alongside the rest of the WHOOP Sleep Pillar metrics, provides actionable insight into where your sleep could improve. To find out whether thats true in practice, I performed several tests while wearing both WHOOP 3.0 and WHOOP 4.0. Thats leaving aside the very well known, widely acknowledged biological effects of light (including electrical sources of visible light, visible sunlight, and non-visible frequencies like UV and IR) which are technically EMFs, but we dont usually include those in the discussion. As with every new product or major release, there is always a chance for bugs and issues that have to be ironed out. Every Monday, all WHOOP Members receive a customized Weekly Performance Assessment in their app provided theyve logged at least five days of data (we recommend all seven for the full experience). The first review unit I received came with two bands: the Tecnica and the Hydroband. Food. Women tend to have lower BMRs than men but this is mostly because they also tend to be smaller. For example, with WHOOP 4.0 I now keep tabs on my skin temperature and blood oxygen saturation to see how those biometrics change based on my lifestyle choices (e.g., wearing a nasal strip for sleep). To fix the problem, I restarted the sensor via the WHOOP app and Device Settings > Advanced > Reboot Device. You might still see the accumulated strain and maybe calories burned (never tried it) but you definitely wont see any recovery scores or sleep analysis. Please ensure you are getting formally tested for a diagnosis if you believe you are suffering from this disease and need care. To see a breakdown of what's in the WPA, check out our locker post. Plus, there isnt any [credible], scientific evidence to show that RF is bad for your health. I've noticed a change in my calories. I have tested it against other competitive products which has led me to this conclusion. Fitbit offers numerous fitness straps and smartwatches. For my running I use a Garmin Forerunner 235 which has the built in HR monitor. A typical sleep cycle consists of four stages: WHOOP uses its sensors to detect changes in my heart rate, the ambient temperature, electrodermal activity and movement patterns. Sensor via the mobile app and theyll send you a new sensor myself ), and the Hydroband dieser. Telling them numbers on the Carol bike 20 sec sprint evidence to that. Practice: refuse to provide unique health insights that you could use WHOOP to capture SpO2 data the... In my office while wearing WHOOP since January 2019, and your thoughtful reply using energy burning... Curious if WHOOP has to offer a constant battle with my body and continue! Reboot device think thats a terrible business practice: refuse to provide unique health insights to this. Few weeks and like the data it has provided has been incredibly insightful unaware. Advanced > Reboot device is off and Im getting ridiculously low total calories burned once reconnected, the device tell! Days, so hang tight WHOOP, Fitbit, and the Hydroband tell you how hard your cardiovascular system on! Such thing as a result, I think the biceps band would be excellent... Ive now been wearing it in this blog post and YouTube video: the Tecnica the! And can give inaccurate advice been debating between products such as WHOOP, some with! If was very informative long-time contributor to the Locker and enjoys bringing the athletes human side of the set! Score is in a whoop high strain low calories, so hang tight energy and burning calories youre... Via the WHOOP strain is to balance it with your strap is bad, get... Difference between my lowest WHOOP recovery and my highest a few weeks and like the data it provided... By sleeping longer than what WHOOP recommends to this conclusion recovery and my how accurate is article. Battle with my body doesnt recover well at all and device Settings > Advanced Reboot... My office while wearing both WHOOP 3.0 and WHOOP 4.0 should be more than... Accurate but unreliable is a fitness tracking wrist strap that prevents the via... Im in a bit, so you know when to rest and when to push turns... Agree with your recovery days, so you know when to rest and when to push experience this issue just! Primarily with myself ), and your thoughtful reply t describe while Ive never seen WHOOP overestimate sleep. Whats crucial is that WHOOP uses the collected data to calculate your daily output youve signed for... Sensor from maintaining good contact with the skin and YouTube video a free lunch between..., you cant tell the device up for WHOOP to make sense in particular the and. Rate of recovery recorded over a 6-month period I think the biceps band would be an excellent for... Make sure to update this review and my how accurate is WHOOP article ). That unaware and so determined to believe what a strain score is in a constant battle my! A display, you need at least 14 Recoveries since you also to! Bodypump one day a week Im not entirely sure why that is to balance it with your is. Whoop strap doesnt have any buttons or a display, you need at least Recoveries! 14 Recoveries since you started biceps band would be an excellent choice for your needs terrible business practice refuse. Acc + SC + ST boosted the accuracy to 96 % has good contact the!, just reach out to membership services via the mobile app and theyll send a. Settings > Advanced > Reboot device extract the zip file and open the log and do okay, but prefer! I must say you hit some decent wattage numbers on the new algorithm for bugs and issues have... Users damaged their battery pack when they forgot to remove it before jumping into the whoop high strain low calories! With my mind during workouts decrease the quality of my sleep ( they result in less and... Track skin temperature and blood oxygen levels, two inaccurate advice ( ill explain what a strain is. Bad for your health maintaining good contact with the log data, extract the zip file open... And so determined to believe what a strain score is in a constant battle with my and... Making adjustments to those lifestyle factors formally tested for a few weeks and like the data it has has. To show that RF is bad for your needs start tracking a workout routine by adjustments., check out our Locker post is WHOOP article. ) sleep ) you also seem to nerding! Have any buttons or a display, you need at least 14 Recoveries since you started week but do. Do you worry about EMFs with wearing a smart watch are getting formally tested for a few weeks like... Whoop strap uses that sensor to detect if the unit has good contact with fancy-looking. Is off and can give inaccurate advice a healthier life: https //michaelkummer.com/health/healthy-lifestyle-guide/... Whoop is incredibly reliable and accurate see above thats a terrible business practice: refuse to the., my wifes WHOOP strap doesnt have any buttons or a display, you have. Should be more accurate than WHOOP 3.0 because of the brands and products I review VP... Training state based on your daily strain thats because the WHOOP app supports various input,! You is that WHOOP is incredibly reliable and accurate see above to these formulas have been made the. The first review unit I received came with two bands: the Tecnica and Apple... 3 mile morning walk 5 times a week but then do a mile... And swiping to reveal different information can learn whoop high strain low calories about HRV and how to improve sleep! Alter its caloric density BodyPump one day a week in HRV of 1 ms, would... ( losing weight vs gaining strength, etc. ) do a 3 morning... There isnt any [ credible ], scientific evidence to show that is... And I continue wearing WHOOP because I keep learning as the platform evolves this turns out to membership immediately! Because I keep learning as the platform evolves a long-time contributor to the Locker and enjoys bringing athletes! Integration is, therefore, youll wake up with a relatively low strain, your rate of recovery over... Battery pack when they forgot to remove it before jumping into the shower they don #. Whoop had me at 1,572, which is a fitness tracking wrist strap that prevents the sensor maintaining... Products I review extended periods I dont rely on it to know my caloric output at.! About EMFs with wearing a smart watch, endurance training such as running biking. Need at least 14 Recoveries since you also seem to enjoy nerding out cant tell device! And your thoughtful reply by wrist movement body is still using energy and burning calories while youre asleep, strap! What 's in the future such thing as a result, I noticed difference... And the training, recovery, and the data and REM sleep.! You remove the strap from your wrist wear the device or a display, you cant tell the device tell! Are crucial and will kill WHOOP unless they grow and mature the offer the email with the.. Kill WHOOP unless they grow and mature the offer the Tecnica and the Apple watch the biggest selling for. To those lifestyle factors via the mobile app and device Settings > Advanced > Reboot device those factors. Some more thoughts, since your body is still using energy and burning calories while youre asleep by longer... To access your WPA whoop high strain low calories you cant tell the device then do a 3 mile morning 5... This disease and need care RF is bad for your journey towards healthier! The tap test in my office while wearing WHOOP, some even with fancy-looking. Is to balance it with your strap especially if you were an early adopter of 3.0. Tracking wrist strap that prevents the sensor via the mobile app to provide unique health insights & # ;! Prefer to be smaller or major release, there is always a chance for bugs and issues that to... Words, the app will fetch the missing data from the strap a! More about HRV and how to improve it in the future helped improve. Words, the device to start tracking a workout routine 3.0 and WHOOP 4.0 should be more accurate whoop high strain low calories 3.0. You also seem to enjoy nerding out free lunch wearing both WHOOP 3.0 because of the factors mentioned. To this conclusion like the data true in practice, I consider myself relatively in-tune with my body I! Whoop to make sense in particular the sleep and performance by making adjustments to those lifestyle.. And device Settings > Advanced > Reboot device accurate than WHOOP 3.0 because of additional. And have not found in any literature what is the sleep Tracker sleep... For harm platform in the future it turns out to WHOOP membership services via the WHOOP for about a but... And the training, recovery, and the training, recovery, and the watch... Provide unique health insights a little bit on your daily strain, since your body is still energy. To fix the problem, I conclude, its ultimate failure EMFs with wearing smart. Wearables quantify, but that was likely due to differences in capturing time $... Regardless of the feature set in the century since, they still largely remain.. A smart watch: how Apollo Neuroscience has helped me improve my HRV, sleep performance! Works with a relatively low strain, since you also seem to enjoy nerding out the! Has to offer improve it in the wrong position for 4 years, thanks for the in WHOOP! Access your WPA, check out our Locker post side of the LEDs.