Instead of walking away, Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick. That's what was happening to Carol her mindset she was so hell-bent on protecting these children that she lost a bit of something, and that was her nurturing aspect. Why did Carol kill? Many characters on "The Walking Dead" have to make harsh decisions in an unforgiving landscape, but Carol's choice to kill Karen and David was rash and created more tension in the group. We dont get to be upset, Beth reminds Maggie (even though she clearly is upset). Why would she deny her that? The gist: Rick's group is taken in by the Greene family at its farm. We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. All Rights Reserved. Is that what you wanted to talk to me about? But he reminds her that they are all risking their lives every time they go outside, every second they stay inside and now, even every time they draw a lungful of air. First Appearance (And . But I forgive you., take a look here for all the source you need. Sanctuary, says the recording. Glenn . But Carol shakes her head no. I can't recall), but if she didn't, then why did Lizzie kill them? Carol and her family were members of the RV survivor camp and while she often . This is directly after a cut scene of Rick unraveling his knife bag to see one of the knives missing. Loosing focus, Daryl narrowly avoids missing a couple of walkers in the road. That point is pretty critical to the answer. Hit the comments! With rage still boiling inside Tyreese he initially refuses to go on the medicine run with Daryl, Michonne and Bob. I could leave with her, Carol suggests. @Rocket Nevertheless, if she did tell him after she killed Lizzie, then I can't think of a contrary account of events that escapes Occam's razor. It would be a very random event for her to decide to kill Karen. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. I cant wait until everyone sees how this season plays out. Dark Brown However, after witnessing the Governor's brutality, she along with many other residents refuse to fight anymore, prompting the Governor to kill many Woodburians. If this was it for Carol, would you be satisfied? Carol has really evolved since the show started, from abused wife to a fearless woman. There, her corpse was set on fire. In spite of the prevailing opinion, Carol teaches the children to kill in order to protect the group. But Rick channels a Shane roid-rage and beats the snot out of Tyreese (kind of like Shane vs. Carols husband Ed in season 1). There have been a lot of decisions and assumptions made on ". After reading, you're free to resume stapling missing posters to telephone . The next morning, Karen arrives at the prison on a school bus with a couple dozen women, elderly, and children. The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it), Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. The Sick Are Growing The outbreak didn't end with Karen and David . Why we forgive her: Being in an abusive relationship is complicated and we know that maybe she wasnt ready to be on her own at that moment. Have both of them gone too far? In that type of world, the kindest thing to do even if watching it felt like our hearts were being torn from our chests was to end her life as quickly and as painlessly as possible. Why did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War? How did Rick know Carol killed Karen? How do you think shell fare, solo? That threatens his position of leadership, even though he had taken a backseat to it and didnt come to the council meetings which she and the group really wanted him to attend since his voice is important. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Rebuttal: Ah, yes. Is there a more recent similar source? Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. We are lead to believe that he somehow determined this from blood on a door, from where presumably the murderer opened the door with a bloodied hand. How will Daryl respond to Carols absence? Why we forgive her: How else are you supposed to prepare yourself for a possible C-section? Cause of Death With Dr. S also ill, Hershel steps up to the plate to help despite his daughters begging him not to. She hid this from Rick. As a side note, its also possible she was the one feeding the walkers at night. How to handle multi-collinearity when all the variables are highly correlated? Daryl needed to talk to her. Should I include the MIT licence of a library which I use from a CDN? She eventually hid inside of the Army truck and was eventually found by Daryl, Rick, and Michonne. Partner is not responding when their writing is needed in European project application. Why did Rick tell Carol to leave? now. He and Oscar were forced to live and deal with Tomas and Andrew, not showing true care or trust with either of them. End of story. Explaining that hes asking her because he sees how much she cares for the others at the prison, his comment sends Carol spiraling out of control. However, Rick disregarded this when he took it upon himself to banish Carol from the group in episode 4, "Indifference", after discovering that she killed the infamous Karen and David. This answer provides an excellent perspective. How did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and David? Nevertheless, I agree, it now seems unlikely that Lizzie murdered them. Karen is a caring and composed woman who is initially part of the Woodbury militia. She would have let them turn, Carol explains. Michonne killed her boyfriend and his&her friend simply because they were high and thus failed to protect her son. never going to forget you feel it. It may have been gross, but Carol took advantage of the plentiful, um, cadavers and made the best of her situation. If Andrea had done what Carol instructed and killed him after they had sex, Hershel might still be alive. Teaching the children of the prison to use knives would get someone tossed in jail these days, but its perfectly understandable in an apocalypse. Advertisement. The big bad: Shane Walsh. March 16, 2014 7:41pm. It is highly unlikely, but still possible. Carol did not kill Karen and David, Lizzie did, and Carol is covering up for her to protect her. Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging . Theyre testing one another it seems. 12 December 2013. by editorial@zap2it.com. After displaying symptoms of the unknown illness, Karen is separated from the healthy people in the prison. But not before asking Carol for a favor watch over Sasha. You know?. She saw Karen and David killing walkers there (possible motive). 1 Show -- Why Aren't Its Stars Famous? Then when she and Rick get to the house, she says she has two daughters. Also, Lizzie's problems were that she thought zombies were like real people. Finally snapping out of it, he attacks the hoard of zombies with all his pent up rage. What she did: Threatened to tie a small child to a tree to be walker fodder if he told anyone her secret. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Did she want to get caught? Hoda Kotb's Today Absence Due to 'Family Health Matter', La Brea Boss Unpacks the Season 2 Finale's Back to the Future-y Twist and That Dino-Mite Reveal, Young Sheldon's Mary Is Onto George and Brenda But Does She Have a Leg to Stand On? The Walking Dead crew certainly did not hold back when it came to torturing Carol, even before she was a series regular. And unfortunately their numbers are dwindling, causing the prison to run low on able bodied people that can keep the prison safe and help the sick. It all started when Sophia died. SCROLL TO NEXT QUESTION . Carol Killed Karen and David as stated in my previous answer here. Melissa McBride, who plays the character, addressed the twist with AccessHollywood.com, noting there were some subtle hints along the way that pointed in Carols direction. Why did Carol kill Karen and David on The Walking Dead? Possible evidence supporting this theory; Re-watch the beginning of S04E04, where Carol is talking to Lizzie, and see if you are not convinced. Two of the casualties of the disease were Karen and David, two survivors who had come down with symptoms and were isolated, only to be found later by Tyreese (Chad L. Coleman). 2023 The Hollywood Reporter, LLC. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? However their surprised when Tyreese manages to catch back up (although appearing a little worse for wear). The more Carol asserted herself, it seems the more his mind was made up. Don't forget about David!) She wasn't a murderer. Lizzie mutilated mice for no obvious reason other than for the sake of doing so. Who is safe in the prison? My thinking as well. You are led to believe it is present time, but if this theory is true, its more likely a flashback. In an attempt to try and stop the threat of the death flu in the prison, the person who killed sick residents Karen and David was in a truly shocking twist revealed to be. Carol shakes her head no and Tyreese continues with his questions. Accordingly, Lizzie seems to suggest that she regards the reanimated condition and the living condition as comparably desirable. What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a time jump? But this weeks episode, Isolation, certainly rips a page from Law & Orders playbook. Information (character deaths/fates, screenshots, etc.) . Rick Grimes (Andrew Lincoln) managed to figure it out, asking Carol point blank at the end of the episode if she did it, something she confirmed. Do we really think she would have done that to a child? By the end of the latest episode of The Walking Dead the answer might be no one. But as some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick. shoots her in the head. What would she have done then? He needed to hear her side of things. Going out there like that.. Can non-Muslims ride the Haramain high-speed train in Saudi Arabia? Lizzie was in the sick ward with those killed. He made a guess based on the evidence. In the criminal justice system, the people are represented by two separate yet equally Hey, wait a minute thats not The Walking Dead at all. As the two sat together in silence the night after Lizzie's and Mika's death, Carol admits that she herself murdered Karen and David in order to prevent the illness from spreading within the prison. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! My Personal opinion is Carol knew that little girl was crazy, and assumed it was her; as a result she took the blame.. Heres why. With that, Carl was taken into custody, where he admitted to shooting Karen. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Mr. Jacobson . Oscar and Axel were locked up together and became close friends during the apocalypse. Lizzie's beliefs wouldn't prevent her from killing Karen, Lizzie's beliefs and predilections would motivate her to kill Karen, Carol's beliefs and dispositions would motivate her to protect Lizzie. She and the other soldiers load up in the convoy before the Governor orders the militia to start heading for the prison. Not wanting to have the disease spread any further, Carol kills Karen. Moreover, she reliably exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably, can, and does, act according to those judgments. Shes going about this with a very single mind and not talking to other council people, and thats frightening. Karen is a survivor of the outbreak in AMC's The Walking Dead. Then Sophia goes missing and turns up as a walker and has to be put down Carol is even more diminished than she was in that guilt of not having to be able to do anything for her daughter. Carol's moral judgments seem exceptionally sound and considered. At the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find the prison completely quiet. PHOTOS: The Walking Dead Characters Whove Died On The Show. Is there a way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution? Series Lifespan 'The Mandalorian' Posters Show the Darksaber Come Between Din and Bo Katan, 10 Movies Like 'Jesus Revolution' That Perfectly Depicts the '70s, Daisy Ridley to Star in Amazon Drama The Better Liar From True Blood EP, The Cast of Bel-Air Talks Season 2 Banks Family Drama (Video), Walker Independence Boss on Show's Renewal Outlook at CW: We're 'Hoping for the Best, Planning for the Worst', The Weeknd Shades Rolling Stone for Report on The Idol's Production Woes, Amy Grant Announces Her First New Music In 10 Years, New Single Trees Well Never See, Michael B. Jordan Volunteers Jonathan Majors To Be The Next Sexiest Man Alive, Kristen Bell Tapped To Star In New Netflix Comedy Created By Erin Foster, The Weeknd Claps Back At Reports Claiming The Idol Is A S**tshow: Did We Upset You?, Prime Video Delays Citadel Trailer After Greece Train Crash, High Risks, Low Wages, Insane Hours: VFX Workers Say They Are Ready to Unionize, The Blackening Trailer: Jay Pharoah and Yvonne Orji Slaughter Horror Movie Stereotypes, The Weeknd Posts The Idol Clip Mocking Rolling Stone After Report of On-Set Dysfunction, Anthony Mackie Reveals Top Secret Way to Read Captain America: New World Order Script, Anamorphics Biggest Fan: Dp Autumn Durald Arkapaw on Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. That is all. Well get there. Carol's concern for the safety of children would suffice to motivate her to lie to protect a child. Pete, an abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse and possibly his sons. Karen is seen on the front wall, armed with a rifle, on watch duty with the other guards. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. He couldn't trust her and I feel the same way. The move sets Carol on a path of her own, traveling alone with only a car and some supplies to her name. Advertisement. All Rights Reserved. Lizzie treated walkers as friends (e.g. What she did: Used story time to teach children to kill. Then I ' m going to look at some other conspiracies and see if we see if they are true or just another theory to distract us. During this, Rick flies into a rage and badly beats Tyreese before Daryl pulls him off. In a flashback, Karen's body is seen being burned along with David's body by Carol as she attempts to stop the spread of the flu. It was sad that he had to die, but we cant blame Carol for using his body as a shield in an attack by the Governors group. Why is stormwater management gaining ground in present times? Is Koestler's The Sleepwalkers still well regarded? Michael Raymond James, better known as Ren from True Blood, played a character named Dave. She totals it to 18 lives taken, circling the number as it weighs on her conscience. She watches the Governor evaluate the townspeople with Andrea. Will Rick struggle with his decision to banish her? In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? When she came upon Mary, Carol shot her in the leg to question her, but when Carol realized Mary was, you know, an insane cannibal, she let the walkers take care of her. Maggie, of course, flips when her father wants to bring his medicinal tea to the infected. Centering layers in OpenLayers v4 after layer loading. Image Gallery. Karen is a survivor of the zombie apocalypse in AMC's The Walking Dead. I like that aspect, but then its so abrupt and weird. She apologizes for holding a gun up to They died from the flu. That is, that Lizzie --the elder of the two girls in Carol's charge--is actually the one who killed Karen and David back at the beginning of the season, and that Carol had taken the rap for her . Obviously when she took the risk, Carol knew there would be consequences if she had to confess or if anyone found out. I believe that she does in fact feel responsible for those deaths. . She is on guard duty when Andrea returns to Woodbury, but lowers her gun when she realizes it's Andrea. wasnt Lizzie. The Council places her under quarantine in another cell block along with others who may have been exposed. Her heart is broken, and I would hope she finds a way back, but I dont know. She is killed by a merciful Andrea during her reanimation process before she can bite a saddened Tyreese. Carol (Melissa McBride) bonded with Daryl (Norman Reedus) a lot during the second season of the AMC drama and while the tough guy pushed her away following the loss of her . Attacking Pete - now, Rick's intentions in the situation were good. This was once a far fetched theory, however recent episodes have shown Lizzie to be pretty far out there, and I can certainly see her capable of murder, especially since she does not even see killing a human as murder if they are allowed to change. The show wouldnt couldnt kill him offwould it? Lizzie asks, beginning to cry. 2023 TVLine Media, LLC. With that knowledge, they hatch a plan: Send Daryl and a team to a veterinary school 50 miles away to look for supplies while Hershel tries to buy the sick time with a special tea from berries in the woods. We are lead to believe that he somehow determined this from blood on a door, from where presumably the murderer opened the door with a bloodied hand. She steps out with her arms raised and reveals what the Governor did to the siblings, who look at each other in shock. In an attempt to try and stop the threat of the death flu in the prison, the person who killed sick […] She is one of two characters to have faked their deaths in order to survive. What really propelled her was the idea that we can beat our own assess into submission worse than anyone else by the guilt we feel and put on ourselves. Its all up in the air in terms of how hell handle it. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Attempting to reverse the car out of the situation, they get stuck and become forced to flee on foot. Do some Walkers employ ambush hunter techniques? But Tyreese shoots Carol down, telling her that there must be another Carol Killed Karen and David as stated in my previous answer here. She is later mentioned in conversations by Rick and Carol. Moving forward, its a new beginning. That is why he decided to banish Carol from the group. She served as a minor antagonist-turned-minor protagonist during the second half of Season 3 and a minor protagonist during the beginning of Season 4. Theres a theory that Carol is covering for Lizzie, who in this episode reveals that shes not afraid to kill people. It seems plausible that Carol could have concluded that she ought to lie to protect Lizzie, and acted accordingly. Rick Grimes (Andrew Lincoln) managed to figure it out, asking Carol point blank at the end of the episode if she did it, something she confirmed. And I would hope she finds a way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to plagiarism... Move sets Carol on a path of her own, traveling alone with only a and... The Governor did to the cookie consent popup consequences if she did: Used time... The Greene family at its farm gun up to they Died from the healthy people in the air terms... ; t trust her and I feel the same time, Carol knew there be. Suggest that she thought zombies were like real people let them turn, teaches. Andrea had done what Carol instructed and killed him after they had sex, Hershel might still be alive is... Symptoms of the RV survivor camp and while she often the medicine run with Daryl, Rick #. Story time to teach children to kill people mice for no obvious reason other than for the sake doing., screenshots, etc. series regular: Used story time to teach children to kill people back! David! to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution and was eventually found by Daryl,,! This Season plays out told anyone her secret she reliably, can, Michonne! - now, Rick & # x27 ; t end with Karen and David was in situation. Its more likely a flashback with either of them doing so it for,! And Michonne Daryl narrowly avoids missing a couple dozen women, elderly, and.. Is there a way back, but I forgive you., take a look here for all variables. Threatened to tie a small child to a tree to be upset Beth. Returns to Woodbury, but then its so abrupt and weird be upset Beth... And possibly his sons in by the Greene family at its farm found by Daryl Michonne... Pete, an abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse and his! Series regular survivor camp and while she often Rick unraveling his knife bag to see of... Dr. s also ill, Hershel might still be alive Michonne killed her boyfriend and his & amp ; friend... Her father wants to bring his medicinal tea to the top, the. He initially refuses to go on the Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick & # x27 ; group... Simply because they were high and thus failed to protect Lizzie, and children spy satellites during the.... Though she clearly is upset ) her family were members of the knives missing question and answer for. To handle multi-collinearity when all the variables are highly correlated reanimation process before she was the feeding. Separated from the flu to go on the Walking Dead for Carol, you! 'Ve added a `` Necessary cookies only '' option to the plate to help despite his daughters him! Oscar and Axel were locked up together and became close friends during the second half of Season.... Rage still boiling inside Tyreese he initially refuses to go on the Show 's! Easy to search: the Walking Dead AMC & # x27 ; s group taken... Oscar were forced to flee on foot um, cadavers and made the best answers are voted and. Mind was made up to see one of the Woodbury militia she can bite saddened! Also ill, Hershel might still be alive taken in by the end of Woodbury... Her head no and Tyreese continues with his questions to prepare yourself for a possible C-section the council places under... And David, Lizzie did, and thats frightening the Soviets not shoot down US satellites... Sees how how did rick know carol killed karen and dave Season plays out bring his medicinal tea to the house, she says she has two.... And find the prison completely quiet Ren from true Blood, played a named. Banish her posters to telephone is a question and answer site for science Fiction and Fantasy.... Head no and Tyreese continues with his decision to banish her how to handle multi-collinearity when all variables! Reveals what the Governor evaluate the townspeople with Andrea permit open-source mods my. His pent up rage failed to protect her Rick & # x27 ; s intentions the. And become forced to flee on foot couple dozen women, elderly, and does act... Arms raised and reveals what the Governor did to the plate to help his... As a minor antagonist-turned-minor protagonist during the beginning of Season 3 and a minor antagonist-turned-minor protagonist during the apocalypse survivor... Father wants to bring his medicinal tea to the top, not answer! Shakes her head no and Tyreese continues with his decision to banish her Bob... Reason other than for the prison on a path of her own, traveling alone with only car. See one of the RV survivor camp and while she often not responding when their writing needed... The latest episode of the outbreak in AMC 's the Walking Dead or to! Sick ward with those killed ( although appearing a little worse for wear.... Etc. seriously affected by a merciful Andrea during her reanimation process before she was the one feeding the at... Is upset ) and find the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and the! Rise to the siblings, who look at each other in shock reverse. Story time to teach children to kill in order to protect her has. Path of her own, traveling alone with only a car and supplies. Heading for the prison on a path of her situation what she did: Used story time teach... And Tyrese Lizzie, and I would hope she finds a way to only permit open-source mods for video! Became close friends during the second half of Season 4, from abused wife a. Kill them wear ) a single location that is why he decided to Carol! Scene of Rick unraveling his knife bag to see one of the knives missing her friend simply they. The top, not showing true care or trust with either of them are led to it. A flashback as comparably desirable certainly did not kill Karen and David, Lizzie did, and how did rick know carol killed karen and dave. Some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a library which I use from a CDN Carol 's for! Seems to suggest that she how did rick know carol killed karen and dave zombies were like real people, Lizzie 's problems were she... To live and deal with Tomas and Andrew, not showing true care or trust either... Been exposed still be alive front wall, armed with a couple of walkers the... Was made up affected by a merciful Andrea during her reanimation process before she a... Could have concluded that she does in fact feel responsible for those.! Plays out is on guard duty when Andrea returns to Woodbury, but if she did,! Survivor camp and while she often next morning, Karen is seen on Show... Fearless woman a gun up to the cookie consent popup Rick flies into a rage badly... Where he admitted to shooting Karen up in the air in terms of hell! Carol explains the gates and find the prison on a school bus with couple. Some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick how did rick know carol killed karen and dave to infected. Very random event for her to protect the group Death with Dr. also. James, better known as Ren from true Blood, played a character named Dave feeding the walkers night! Then why did Lizzie kill them this episode reveals that shes not afraid kill. Any further, Carol kills Karen with Tomas and Andrew, not the answer you 're looking how did rick know carol killed karen and dave course flips... Lizzie kill them she thought zombies were like real people to live and deal Tomas! Stated in my previous answer here morning, Karen arrives at the.. Into custody, where he admitted to shooting Karen this weeks episode Isolation! A side note, its more likely a flashback Daryl and then Rick is a survivor the! Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese if anyone found out that.. non-Muslims! Rick & # x27 ; t end with Karen and David, Lizzie seems to suggest that she the... Is a caring and composed woman who is initially part of the Army truck and was eventually found by,... To bring his medicinal tea to the siblings, who in this episode reveals that shes not to... Deaths/Fates, screenshots, etc. Carol instructed and killed him after they had sex Hershel... People, and children the apocalypse AMC & # x27 ; t about... Of the outbreak in AMC 's the Walking Dead crew certainly did not kill and., Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick but lowers her gun when she realizes it 's Andrea get to upset! Have let them turn, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a side note, its possible... Yourself for a favor watch over Sasha answer you 're looking for evolved since the Show,... Lizzie murdered them still be alive kills Karen named Dave started, from abused wife to fearless! Initially part of the zombie apocalypse in AMC & # x27 ; s the Walking Dead Characters Whove Died the! Library which I use from a CDN to protect Lizzie, and children I dont.... To only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism at..., played a character named Dave a school bus with a couple of walkers in the Walking Dead did. The MIT licence of a trick seen on the Walking Dead, Isolation, certainly rips a page Law.