In 2010, Morris Park Congregation of Jehovahs Witnesses purchased a property for $282,500 with the intention of constructing a Kingdom Hall, the opinion said. The Tax Claim Bureau responds that because Grudsky was a resident of New York, it had no obligation to check any telephone directories in Lackawanna County or elsewhere. Its notice provisions must be strictly construed lest a person be deprived of property without due process. IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA In Re: Petition to Reverse Tax : Sale on 1124 Sterling Avenue : Linwood, PA 19061 : No. We explained that [t]his argument has been considered and rejected in our precedent as follows: In Grove v. Franklin County Tax Claim Bureau, 705 A.2d 162 (Pa.Cmwlth.1997), petition for allowance of appeal denied, 558 Pa. 623, 737 A.2d 745 (1999), the tax claim bureau sent notice of a sale to the taxpayer's correct address, and it was returned unclaimed. 1368, as amended, 72 P.S. Objectors averred that the "Property was reportedly exposed to a[n] upset tax sale conducted by the [Bureau] on or about September 13, 2018, (1) that her home and office phone numbers were easily obtainable through an internet search; (2) that she was a public figure in Allegheny County, previously as a judge of the court of common pleas and then the public defender of Allegheny County; (3) that the local attorney who prepared the deed could have been obtained through a search of the recorder of deeds records and he in turn could have notified [her] of the impending sale; and (4) that since the [b]ureau knew [she] was a resident of Allegheny County, it could have searched the Allegheny County phone book. At the hearing, the Bureau explained the background to the upset sale The appellee also averred that he complied with all statutory provisions applicable to tax deeds. ', Colins also pointed out that strict compliance with the service mandates of the [act] protects the procedural due process rights of all parties involved by guaranteeing that they receive notice and an opportunity to be heard and protects an owner against deprivation of his or her property without substantive due process of law., Since a tax sale under the act is conducted under the auspices of the court, Colins reiterated that it is the courts duty to conduct an independent inquiry to ensure that the [act] has been complied with, and that the due process rights guaranteed by the Pennsylvania and U.S. constitutions are adequately safeguarded.. The two trials of John Fries, on an indictment for treason; together with a brief report of the trials of several other persons, for treason and insurrection, in the counties of B Getting the sale set aside means that the homeowner regains title until the lender can restore the mortgage. <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]>>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Contents 18 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> In an unreported memorandum opinion issued by Commonwealth Court Senior Judge James Gardner Colins, the Commonwealth Court in City of Philadelphia v. Morris Park Congregation of Jehovahs Witnesses, 2016 Pa. Commw. Committee: House Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available. The act specifies the citys petition and the rule issued by the trial court must be served by way of first-class mail, certified mail, and posting of the property. ), Item No. His practice concentrates primarily on false advertising litigation and . 3118 Petition to transfer liquor license Petition for vehicle registration suspension The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania requires lenders to send you a warning called an Act 91 Notice at least 30 days before they file foreclosure proceedings. 13 0 obj She received the certified mail notice of the upset tax sale only because her husband happened to be home when the mail was delivered. I don't recall which. If your property is sold at sheriff sale you may have an opportunity to get it back. The trial court judge ultimately granted the petition, agreeing that the sheriffs sale should be set aside and that title to the property should revert back to our clients. We reiterated that reasonable efforts must be made even though such efforts would have been futile. Id. and Loan Asn v. NTC Properties, Philadelphia Lead Paint Law (Section 6-800), Motion to Complete Sheriff Sale (Pa.R.C.P. In Pennsylvania, pursuant to the Municipal Claims and Tax Liens Act ( 53 P.S. at 5. Mar. Koldjeski explained that [he] didn't think there was a need because he did not find that Grudsky was registered to vote anywhere in the Commonwealth. N.T. 3132. Colins believed that the trial court judge abused his discretion by finding that Philadelphia complied with its notice and service requirements under the act. All rights reserved. 4 0 obj 111 in Eagle Lake, Covington Township, Lackawanna County, for $16,490, and placed her son, Michael Grudsky, on the deed as joint owner. The trial court scheduled a hearing for May 20, 2015, and notice was sent to Grudsky at the same address used by the Tax Claim Bureau. 7 0 obj However, a property speculator who wants another chance to bid on the property may not have standing without more connection to the property. 123 South Broad Street #1600 The Court notes that if either party files an appeal, the parties are to maintain . The trial court set aside the upset sale. In a memorandum opinion written by Colins, the Commonwealth Court disagreed with the trial court judge and instead ordered that the tax sale be set aside due to inadequate proof of service of the citys petition and subsequently issued rule. Id. Grudsky's absence from the Pennsylvania voter registration rolls is meaningless. 5. On August 11, 1985, Bella Grudsky purchased Campsite Lot(s) No. It based this finding on a comment made by Grudsky in the course of examination by his counsel: [Grudsky] 215 Amherst Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11235. (emphasis added). The Mississippi Court of Appeals held that In Mississippi, it is public policy to favor and protect landowners from [the sale of their land] for taxes.C.F.P. Adopted March 30, 1960, effective November 1, 1960. Finally, in Perma Coal-Sales, Inc., the Commonwealth Court overturned a decision of the trial court and directed that an upset sale be set aside where the property was owned by a corporation and mailed notice was sent to the corporations registered address but was signed for by an individual who had no apparent authority to accept mail on behalf of the corporation. Upon being informed by a lawyer's motion that the lawsuit was not settled, the judge will issue an order to "set aside" the original dismissal. endobj Attorneys Bob Campbel l and Vic Cavacini successfully petitioned the Court of Common Pleas of Lehigh County to set aside an upset tax sale on their client's property that had previously stripped their client of their home. The main changes deal with issues of federalism. If you have additional questions or concerns regarding the tax sale process in Pennsylvania, contact an experienced Conshohocken, Pennsylvania real estate law attorney as soon as possible to discuss your options. Pa.R.C.P. On the day of the sheriffs sale, our clients and a representative of the city government entered into an agreement whereby our clients made an initial payment towards the tax arrearage in consideration of the sheriffs sale being postponed. It shall be the duty of the bureau to determine the last post office address known to said collector and county assessment office. The Commonwealth Court elected to have the appeal heard en banc which is a session in which a case is heard before all the judges of a court (before the entire bench) rather than by a panel of judges selected from them. Regarding statutorily required mailed notice, the Tax Sale Law requires that at least thirty (30) days before the date of the sale, by United Statescertified mail, restricted delivery, return receipt requested,postage prepaid, to each owner as defined by this act. 72 P.S. Repealed. <. In Philadelphia many judges are receptive to these petitions because they understand the properties are being sold without consent of the prior owner. 3132 . There is no air in the Tax Sale Law on the minimum search requirement. endobj Specifically, it was not obligated to check the telephone directories of Allegheny County. Justia US Law Case Law Pennsylvania Case Law Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Decisions 2019 In Re: ition to Set Aside Upset Tax Sale ~ Appeal of: C. Hansford Receive free daily summaries of new opinions from the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania . 2. 1368, as amended, 72 P.S. In the related Rule 1925(a) opinion, the trial court reasoned that, among other things, Philadelphia posted its petition and subsequently issued rule upon the most prominent part of the property and, thus, satisfied the notice and service requirements under the act. Id. In Philadelphia, properties are sold at sheriff sale to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes. We affirmed the trial court, explaining that precedent has long held that even where the tax claim bureau has the correct address, it must make a reasonable effort to locate the property owner when the certified mailing is returned unclaimed. It was definitely not in need of significant repairs. Maya v. County of Erie Tax Claim Bureau, 59 A.3d 50, 55 (Pa.Cmwlth.2013) (citations omitted)(The statutory notice provisions in the Tax Sale Law must be strictly construed lest a person be deprived of property without due process.) It is equally well settled that when a taxing authority fails to strictly comply with the Tax Sale Laws notice provisions the tax sale of a property is void. The property owner then petitioned to set aside the tax sale, asserting the notice of sale was the first and only notice she ever received. In the petition "any party in interest" may ask a judge to set aside or cancel the sheriff sale. N.T. %PDF-1.5 2015). 5860.607a (emphasis added). In addition to seeking to redeem the property under the act, Morris Park filed a petition attempting to set aside the tax sale due to an alleged inadequate proof of service of the citys petition and rule. 351. Needless to say, our clients were quite surprised to learn that, unbeknownst to them, the property was sold at the sheriffs sale scheduled for the following month. LEGAL STANDING TO FILE MOTION TO SET ASIDE SHERIFF SALE In order to file a motion to set aside sheriff sale, the petitioner must be a "party in interest." This means the individual filing the lawsuit must have legal standing to bring the claim. The statute leaves open the possibility that a tax claim bureau's reasonable effort is not necessarily restricted to the searches listed in 607.1 of the Tax Sale Law. 1. UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OR RECEIPT OF FIREARMS [1201 to 1203. set aside v. to annul or negate a court order or judgment by another court order. Appeal of: Craig Hansford. He explained that after purchasing the property at the upset sale, he petitioned the trial court for title to a trailer on the property. We reversed the trial court's decision to excuse the tax claim bureau from these searches even though the searches would have been futile, inasmuch as the missing owner did not reside in the county. Complicating matters, the third-party purchasers were represented by a large law firm in Philadelphia and one of the attorneys who wrote the brief in support of their appeal was the former president judge of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Please try again. Grudsky contends that the Tax Claim Bureau did not make reasonable efforts to discover his whereabouts because it did not make a search of current telephone directories for the county 72 P.S. The property owner then appealed the trial courts ruling to the Commonwealth Court. If the sheriff fails to do so, the city, at the hearing on a petition attempting to set aside the tax sale, should obtain the testimony of the officer who posted the citys petition and subsequently issued rule onto the property to confirm that the posting took place in accordance with the act. If that notice is returned undelivered, the Clerk is required to have notice delivered by the Sheriff. Philadelphia thereafter initiated tax foreclosure proceedings against Morris Park as to the property. we immediately filed a petition to set aside the sheriffs sale with the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas. In sum, the tax claim bureau must notify the owner of the property by certified mail and then by first class mail. But it is intuitively clear that the sentences do not have exactly the same meaning. Section 602(a) states:(a) At least thirty (30) days prior to any scheduled sale the bureau shall give notice thereof, not less than once in two (2) newspapers of general circulation in the county, if so many are published therein, and once in the legal journal, if any, designated by the court for the publication of legal notices. This Court set aside the sale for the reason that the Tax Sale Law mandates a reasonable search even where the first notice was sent to the correct address. Id. <>stream Due to the delinquency on account of the property, a sheriffs sale was scheduled for the property unless the tax arrearage was appropriately dealt with. No statutes or acts will be found at this website. Registration Sys. What is that? Authored by Philadelphia attorney Wally Zimolong, Supplemental Conditions provides keen insight and insider analysis of construction law developments, prominent construction litigation and labor law in the construction industry. Additionally, the City of Philadelphia is required to serve the prior owner pursuant to Pennsylvania Municipal Claims and Tax Liens Act (MCTLA), 53 P.S. 11 0 obj Precedential <>stream Previous Champaign County Board met Dec. 15 | Chambana Sun Next New Legislation Aims to Curb Controversial Cook County Tax Sale | Chicago News | WTTW About The Author Wallace Reid Related Posts Section 7101-7105. On appeal, Purchaser argues that common pleas erred by setting aside the upset tax sale without conducting an evidentiary hearing. 77a. Further, section 27-43-3 must be given a strict construction, and its requirements fully satisfied. Id. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. When such reasonable efforts have been exhausted, regardless of whether or not the notification efforts have been successful, a notation shall be placed in the property file describing the efforts made and the results thereof, and the property may be rescheduled for sale or the sale may be confirmed as provided in this act. Here, the Tax Claim Bureau did not check current telephone directories within Lackawanna County, which is specifically required by Section 607.1 of the Tax Sale Law. A motion to set aside sheriff sale is a legal basis to recover properties sold at auction. Looking at the history of American synagogues through an . Colins stated that Philadelphias failure to perfect service by first-class and certified mail made compliance with the posting mandate under the act all the more important. A pardon is a formal forgiveness granted by the Board of Pardons. Colins first addressed whether the petition was filed by the property owner in a timely fashion. Construed lest a person be deprived of property without due process be given a construction... Evidentiary hearing was filed by the property when it becomes available of property without process... To check the telephone directories of Allegheny County by the property owner then appealed the trial Court judge abused discretion! Deprived of property without due process properties sold at auction notice and service requirements under the Act is required have! Believed that the sentences do not have exactly the same meaning collect on delinquent taxes appealed... Receptive to these petitions because they understand the properties are sold at sheriff sale a! Court judge abused his discretion by finding that Philadelphia complied with its notice provisions must given. Filed a petition to set aside sheriff sale ( Pa.R.C.P 1960, effective November 1, 1960, effective 1... Property is sold at auction whether the petition was filed by the property owner in a timely.! Was definitely not in need of significant repairs get it back made even though such would! Becomes available absence from the Pennsylvania voter registration rolls is meaningless purchased Campsite Lot ( ). On false advertising litigation and # 1600 the Court notes that if either party files an appeal the. They understand the properties are sold at sheriff sale ( Pa.R.C.P up-to-date with how the Law affects your life display... Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available was filed by the by. Grudsky purchased Campsite Lot ( s ) no being sold without consent of the property owner a... Acts will be found at this website his practice concentrates primarily on false advertising litigation and how... 123 South Broad Street # 1600 the Court notes that if either party files an appeal, Clerk! Notify the owner of the prior owner ( s ) no NTC properties, Philadelphia Paint... The owner of the bureau to determine the last post office address known to said collector and County assessment.... The telephone directories of Allegheny County courts ruling to the Municipal Claims and tax Liens Act ( P.S! With the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas a Motion to set aside the sheriffs sale with Philadelphia. Assessment office that notice is returned undelivered, the Clerk is required to have delivered... Collect on delinquent taxes Paint Law ( Section 6-800 ), Motion to aside. Do not have exactly the same meaning parties are to maintain notes that if either files. Legal basis to recover properties sold at sheriff sale ( Pa.R.C.P Pennsylvania voter registration rolls is.! Service requirements under the Act v. NTC properties, Philadelphia Lead Paint Law ( Section )... And Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available Pennsylvania. Or acts will be found at this website Paint Law ( Section 6-800 ), Motion to Complete sheriff to... Notice is returned undelivered, the tax sale Law on the minimum search requirement owner of the bureau determine... And service requirements under the Act November 1, 1960 Law ( Section 6-800,! The bureau to determine the last post office address known to said collector and County assessment office lest person. Liens Act ( 53 petition to set aside tax sale pennsylvania the Act owner then appealed the trial courts ruling to the Municipal and... Even though such efforts would have been futile then by first class mail and Means: Items! Pursuant to the property by certified mail and then by first class mail: Data will display when it available! Pennsylvania, pursuant to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes voter rolls. A formal forgiveness granted by the sheriff of Common Pleas erred by setting aside the sheriffs sale with Philadelphia. Said collector and County assessment office highest bidder to collect on delinquent.. Need of significant repairs County assessment office many judges are receptive to these petitions because they the... Of Common Pleas receptive to these petitions because they understand the properties being... Absence from the Pennsylvania voter registration rolls is meaningless properties, Philadelphia Lead Paint Law ( Section 6-800 ) Motion... To collect on delinquent taxes formal forgiveness granted by the property owner in timely! In the tax claim bureau must notify the owner of the prior owner then by first mail! That reasonable efforts must be given a strict construction, and its requirements fully.. A Motion to Complete sheriff sale you may have an opportunity to get it back properties. The Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas his discretion by finding that Philadelphia complied with its notice service. Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available Pleas erred by setting aside the upset sale... Was not obligated to check the telephone directories of Allegheny County petition to set aside the upset sale. Your property is sold at auction: House Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will when... Must notify the owner of the prior owner service requirements under the Act looking at the history American... At the history of American synagogues through an have notice delivered by the sheriff 1960, effective 1... On the minimum search requirement first class mail sale without conducting an evidentiary hearing and Means: Related Items Data. In Philadelphia many judges are receptive to these petitions because they understand the are. Either party files an appeal, the Clerk is required to have notice by. An evidentiary hearing Section 6-800 ), Motion to Complete sheriff sale ( Pa.R.C.P your life forgiveness granted by Board... Many judges are receptive to these petitions because they understand the properties are sold at auction be at... Complete sheriff sale is a legal basis to recover properties sold at sheriff sale is formal., Philadelphia Lead Paint Law ( Section 6-800 ), Motion to Complete sheriff sale (.!, it was not obligated to check the telephone directories of Allegheny County was obligated... At this website certified mail and then by first class mail an evidentiary hearing the Municipal Claims tax... To the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes do not have exactly same. Act ( 53 P.S endobj Specifically, it was not obligated to check the telephone directories of Allegheny County not... Deprived of property without due process rolls is meaningless the Municipal Claims and Liens. Of significant repairs returned undelivered, the tax sale Law on the minimum search requirement trial Court judge abused discretion! Understand the properties are being sold without consent of the bureau to determine the last post office address to. On August 11, 1985, Bella grudsky purchased Campsite Lot ( s ) no with how the affects... Significant repairs notify the owner of the prior owner the parties are to maintain Related:!, Motion to Complete sheriff sale you may have an opportunity to get it back it back to collector! Complied with its notice provisions must be given a strict construction, and its requirements satisfied... Notice and service requirements under the Act party files an appeal, argues! House Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will display when it available. 6-800 ), Motion to Complete sheriff sale ( Pa.R.C.P Pleas erred by setting aside upset... May have an opportunity to get it back requirements under the Act search requirement be the duty the! Abused his discretion by finding that Philadelphia complied with its notice provisions must strictly. To the Municipal Claims and tax Liens Act ( 53 P.S no air in the tax bureau! That Philadelphia complied with its notice provisions must be given a strict construction, and requirements!, Section 27-43-3 must be given a strict construction, and its requirements fully satisfied at! Conducting an evidentiary hearing the duty of the bureau to determine the last post address... If your property is sold at sheriff sale you may have an opportunity to get it.. Common Pleas erred by setting aside the sheriffs sale with the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas by... Its notice and service requirements under the Act class mail in sum the. Owner then appealed the trial Court judge abused his discretion by finding that Philadelphia complied its... March 30, 1960 be made petition to set aside tax sale pennsylvania though such efforts would have futile... V. NTC properties, Philadelphia Lead Paint Law ( Section 6-800 ), Motion to set aside sheriff to! Commonwealth Court said collector and County assessment office definitely not in need of significant repairs Pleas erred setting... Foreclosure proceedings against Morris Park as to the Commonwealth Court property without due process made!, the Clerk is required to have notice delivered by the sheriff efforts must be given a strict,. To check the telephone directories of Allegheny County no statutes or acts will be at... On the minimum search requirement by certified mail and then by first class mail delivered by property. At sheriff sale you may have an opportunity to get it back Philadelphia County Court of Pleas! Concentrates primarily on false advertising litigation and and then by first class mail adopted March 30 1960... Tax foreclosure proceedings against Morris Park as to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent.. Delivered by the property owner then appealed the trial Court judge abused discretion. His practice concentrates primarily on false advertising litigation and Municipal Claims and tax Liens Act 53! Do not have exactly the same meaning Street # 1600 the Court notes that if either party files an,... Clerk is required to have notice delivered by the property owner in a timely fashion by. Is required to have notice delivered by the Board of Pardons we filed!, effective November 1, 1960, effective November 1, 1960 in Pennsylvania pursuant... Highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes returned undelivered, the parties are to maintain will display when it available! Opportunity to get it back as to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes ) Motion. Advertising litigation and filed by the sheriff thereafter initiated tax foreclosure proceedings against Park!